Top 10 Car Insurance Companies

top 10 car insurance companiesEvery year JD Power and Associates ranks the Top 10 car insurance companies from top-to-bottom. While 2012 is over half-way behind us, it takes a while for the results of the previous year to be calculated. In reality, JD Power ranks 32 Auto insurers in all. We could easily publish them all, but who in the world is going to want to call an auto insurance company that couldn’t even make the top-10? The Top-10 Car Insurance Companies is probably a more meaningful list to give us a starting point in choosing the best match for our needs. Auto insurance companies are ranked on a variety of criteria:

Top 10 Car Insurance Companies

Ratings Criteria

  • Experience of Customer
  • Options Offered by Car Insurance Company
  • Policies offered by Auto Insurer
  • Quality of Billing and Payment
  • Policy and Premium Pricing

Let’s be honest: most of us look at price first when shopping for car insurance. That’s only natural – we cannot really judge the experience and customer service satisfaction until we’ve spent some time with our insurer – and hopefully, we have very little occasion to call them – except of course when we change automobiles. JD Power and Associates a rather informal rating scale that goes like this:

Top-10 Car Insurance Companies Rating Scale

  • Among the Best
  • Better than Most
  • About Average
  • The Rest

If Among the Best, ranks as an A, that means, The Rest, must rank as a D since there is no fifth lowest position in the rankings. Perhaps, JD Power and Associates doesn’t want to offend anyone too badly? Among the Top-10 Car Insurance companies, there are none that rank worse than a C or, About Average.

Top 10 Car Insurance Companies Rated for 2011

A-Rated Insurance Companies

  • Amica Insurance

B-Rated Insurance Companies

  • Erie Insurance
  • Shelter
  • Auto-Owners Insurance
  • Ameriprise
  • State Farm

C-Rated Insurance Companies

  • Geico
  • State Auto
  • American Family
  • Industry Average
  • Alfe Insurance

D-Rated Insurance Companies

Do we really want to talk about those?

Please follow and like us:

VSP Vision Insurance

VSP Vision Insurance

VSP is a vision insurance plan that covers routine eye exams, eye glass lens, eye glass frames and contact lenses. Let’s face it, buying any type of individual insurance is a real drag on the finances and monthly cash flow. Insurance is something you don’t want to use very often and when you do, it is still not likely to make things completely free. Eyeglasses cost a lot of money. In fact, the purchase of a new pair of glasses can cost up to 4 times as much as your actual eye exam. Obviously, not all eye insurance plans are going to cover the cost of your glasses or contact lenses, but it could certainly pay-off to have some of those expenses covered. If your employer doesn’t offer you something like the VSP or another vision insurance plan, you’ll be glad to know it is available to individuals without employee coverage plans for optical insurance. A few months ago, I found a couple of good Individual Dental Plans. Once of these affordable dental plans was good enough to replace even the employer-sponsored Dental Plan I have through my company. Is the same true with Individual Vision Insurance or VSP? I do not have a vision insurance plan through my employer, but wife does through her school district. The vision insurance plan through the school would cost us about $28 a month out of pocket for the family. Most plans like these include free eye exams, $100-$150 on glasses frames and and many of them cover free eye glass lenses and contacts. Now, I’m no dummy. I know what a racket those eyeglasses stores can be. You’ll want anti-glare, scratch resistant lenses; thinner lenses; better lenses and you will end up paying much more above and beyond the free lenses provided by your vision insurance plan. None-the-less, a vision insurance plan might save you some money if you’re taking 4 or 5 members of your family to the eye doctor once a year. Let’s take a look at the VSP Vision Insurance plan which offers private coverage for individuals:

What is Covered under the VSP Vision Insurance Plan?

  • Full Cost of Routine Eye Exams
  • Full Coverage for Prescription Lenses, including bifocals, trifocals and polycarbonate lens for children
  • Cost of Frames up to $120, plus 20% off any out of pocket costs
  • Up to a $120 allowance for the cost of your Contact Lens Exam and Lenses

If you’ve been to your eye doctor recently, you probably have a rough idea of what your out-of-pocket costs of eye exams, lenses, eye glass frames, etc. are (with or without vision insurance). So, do you really save money with a VSP Vision Insurance Plan? It depends. Before we answer that question, we need to know what it costs to enroll in the VSP Vision Insurance plan that matches your family size.


The VSP Vision Insurance Plan requires an $18.00 per year CCA Membership fee.  I’ve added the CCA Fee into the costs below:

  • Just for You: (1 Person): $178.95 Annually or $14.92 Per Month
  • For You + 1 Family Member: $323.95 Annually or $27.00 Per Month
  • For Entire Family of 3 Plus:  $436.95 Annually or $36.00 Per Month

Your reaction to the VSP vision premiums above, probably ranges from “that’s not so bad”,  to “Holy Smoke! VSP Vision Insurance is Expensive!”.. The older we are the more likely we fall into the latter category of sticker shock at the Vision Insurance Premiums. There is a very good reason for that:

Is the VSP Plan worth it for Individuals?

While we are young and near sighted or far sighted, our eyes seem to change constantly. If you have two or more children, you are probably taking them once or twice a year to the eye doctor to get them fitted for glasses or contact lenses. Us older folks (25 and up), are probably going to an eye doctor no more than once or twice every five years. I realize  optometrists tell us that we all need to go at least once a year, but most of us don’t follow that advice unless we have some type of ongoing vision problems. The same is true for my wife and even our kids are at the age where they really don’t need to visit the eye doctor more than once every couple of years. Do the math: For my family, we wouldn’t even break even with the VSP Insurance Premium of $436.95 annually. On the other hand, if I could go back 15 years, when I was taking my kids to the eye doctor and paying for eye exams, new glasses and contact lenses at least once a year, my out-of-pocket expenses for eye exams, glasses and contact lenses was approximately $1,000 per year. I could have saved some money, to the tune of around $400-$500 per year, with the VPS Insurance plan. Vision Insurance is always a bonus if it’s completely paid for by your company. But, if you’re shopping for your own individual vision plan, consider how many times you and your family use an eye doctor. If it is 2 or more visits a year for new prescriptions in glasses and/or contact lenses, you should consider the VSP Plan. Certainly, there are other good insurance plans out there for your eye-sight, but VSP seems to make the most sense for those who need eye insurance and cannot get it through their employee health plan. Deciding whether or not to make monthly payments on vision plan (or any insurance plan for that matter) is kind of like being a back seat driver. It’s always easier to make that decision with the benefit of hindsight. I’ve always recommended that shoppers of any type of insurance check with relatives and friends who were once in their own situation and ask them if they’re happy with what they are getting received for their premium payments. Since we don’t have the benefit of hindsight when shopping for a vision insurance plan, the best advice we can receive is from those who have been in our same shoes. Look into VSP – It is better to be nearsighted than short-sighted.

Please follow and like us:

Car Insurance Ratings

Car Insurance Ratings
Top-10 Auto Insurers

The latest 2010 car insurance ratings are now posted online from JD Powers.  Previously, we posted the Car Insurance Ratings for 2008, here: 2008 Car Insurance Ratings. Not a whole lot of details are given on the JD Powers website about how they come up with these particular car insurance ratings.  The results this year are very similar to their insurance ratings from 2008 and 2009.  Every year, JD Powers rate the best automobile insurers on 5 different criteria:


  1. Overall Satisfaction
  2. Contacting the Insurer
  3. Policy Offerings
  4. Billing and Payment
  5. Pricing

Using this same data, Product Review Ratings breaks these ratings down into a Top-10 Car Insurers List: The difference in these Top-10 insurance, is that the overall satisfaction score is averaged in along with the other five criteria to derive an Overall Rating score on a 100 point scale. Using this embellished set of criteria, the outcome changes ever so slightly over the original JD Powers Ratings and should provide a clearer picture of which car insurance companies rate best, overall. Product Review Ratings Auto Insurance Ratings criteria are as follows:

  • Experience: (Customer’s Overall Satisfaction)
  • Options: (Car Insurers Policy Offerings)
  • Pricing: (Car Insurance Policy Price)
  • Billing: (Satisfaction with billing methods and issues)
  • Contact: (Contacting the Insurer)
  • Overall: (Overall Rating based on above scores, 1-100)

Ratings 2011

This Top-10 list should be used as a guide only – a rough place to get started. Look at the top-10 insurers by JD Powers and compare for yourself. The insurance ratings are not all created equal. Unfortunately, JD Powers does not offer a detailed report on how they came up with the insurance ratings in each of these categories. One huge factor that is not taken into account, here, is how combining auto insurance with a homeowners insurance policy can drastically reduce your Auto Insurance cost or vice versa. Some of the cheapest-looking car insurance companies aren’t as cheap as they seem when you factor in a home owners discount. For those of us who own homes, it doesn’t pay to switch to a cheaper auto insurance company if the cost of a home owners policy negates those savings. For the 2nd time in the three year period that I’ve reviewed these car insurance ratings, Amica has come up on top. I was unable to go back and see if the 2009 JD Powers auto Insurance Ratings reported the same. With Amica receiving perfect scores in every category every year, including cost, I would expect to know a few very satisfied Amica Car Insurance Policy owners. This was not the case. Since writing the 2008 article on auto insurance ratings, I’ve recommended Amica a few times to family and friends. Surprisingly, I have yet to find one person who switched after giving Amica a call? Why? Because, Amica was not as cheap as their current auto insurance policy. For a company who ranks best on price year after year, this is kind of surprising isn’t it? In fact, Amica is the only auto insurance company JD Powers ranks a perfect 5 of 5 stars for price. I can only think of a few things that could cause this discrepancy. Obviously, a great deal of other variables come into play: Credit Rating, geographic area, Home-Owners, demographics, driving record and even the type of cars being insured could reflect a different outcome for some people shopping the same insurance company. The lesson here is that what works for some may not be what is best for everyone. Still, if you’re looking for place to get started, these Top-10 car insurers will serve as a great short-list of places to call first.

Top 10: Car Insurance Ratings

top 10 insurance ratings

Please follow and like us:

Best Life Insurance Rates

best life insurance rates
Life Insurance Ratings

Why worry about Life Insurance Rates or ratings? Things like term insurance, etc., etc.. – all sounds kind of boring, doesn’t it? Choosing a Life insurance policy is one of the most important, yet boringly, daunting financial decisions we can make in our life times. The reason is quite simple: It’s hard to get excited about buying something we hope we never have to use. We love buying products that we want to use, not products we hope we never have to use. Why worry about Life Insurance rates? Such is life. A necessity, but hardly anything to get excited about.  Life Insurance is a Must-Do, not a Want-To-Do item in our lives. So, we look for the best life insurance rates and answer other questions like whole life insurance, universal life insurance, term life insurance rates. If you want cheap life insurance, you’ll have to do your home work; and you’ll need a medical exam. We go through all the trouble for our family; the same reason we need health insurance. These days, you don’t need to get insurance quotes from an agent; you can shop for life insurance rates, online. Either way, insurers are competing to give you the best life insurance rates.

How to find the Best Life Insurance

Why Life Insurance Ratings Count

Consumer advocate groups such as A.M Best Company, provide life insurance ratings on the top life insurance companies in America. Life Insurance Ratings on short-term, mid-termand long-term life insurance companies are based on several factors. Service, price, company stability are among the top criteria used to provide these annual life insurance ratings. Unfortunately, most of these consumer research advocates charge us a price tag to uncover the best life insurance ratings as part of their analysis. Companies like A.M Best are more geared towards providing us with a life insurance company’s financial stability, but charge us for the rest of the information. This sort of defeats the purpose of trying to save money on your term life insurance premium, doesn’t it?

Best Life Insurance Rates Through Referrals

Years ago, I found a really good insurance carrier thanks to a friend who referred me, and I realized that this is how most of us shop for term life insurance. We shop by premium from friends or relatives that had similar needs and told us what they pay. Keep in mind, there are a variety of factors that can influence these ratings. For one thing, when we sign up for a new policy, we are required to have a medical physical. In most cases, the life insurance company will send a registered nurse to your work or office to administer the physical. Your rates will go up dramatically if you smoke, and just slightly if you have ‘high’ cholesterol or are considered by their standards, overweight. It varies by insurance company how much of an impact your physical health with have on your life insurance premium. The other thing that will greatly impact rates from one Life Insurance company to another, is the amount of coverage. On average, most young to middle-aged, primary bread-winners are usually getting lump sum life insurance coverage that is 10-20 times greater than their annual income. The premiums from some life insurance carriers might be better for higher coverage amounts or vice versa. Determining which Life Insurance Carrier is best, is not that much different than comparing Cell Phone plans, where certain carriers are geared better for some people’s needs, requirements and desires than others. For the majority of us, the first place to determine a carrier is to shop for the best rates. Fortunately, there is an organization which provides us with Life Insurance Rankings based on Premiums. The Insurance Information Institute provides an annual ranking of the Top-10 life insurance companies. For your convenience, I have included their ratings of the rates, below.

Top-10 Life Insurance Ratings

  1. MetLife
  2. Prudential Financial
  3. New York Life
  5. Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance
  6. Northwestern Mutual
  7. Aflac
  8. Genworth Financial
  9. Principal Financial
  10. Lincoln Financial


Best Term Life Deals Come Through Friends

Life Insurance Ratings are only Part of the Equation

Ironically, the list above does not include the company I use for my own life insurance, First Penn. In fact, First Penn offered me better premium rates than the one at the very top of the list. So, while top ten Lists are a good starting point, the ultimate way to find the best carrier is to find people, friends and relatives you know whom roughly match your own profile and ask them about their own term policy. Lastly, you will want to compare your friend’s recommendation to the insurance company rating that is provided by a company like A.M Best or Moody’s. This information can be found on the internet in the form of  letter ratings such as AAA or A++,  or simply described in words like exceptional, strong or very strong.  Finding a good life insurance policy is really a two step process; life insurance ratings are the third.

  • Shop Friend’s Advice
  • Compare Friend’s to Company Stability Ratings
  • Check out the Life Insurance Ratings

When said friend recommends an insurance company with a reasonable premium and a strong financial stability rating, you’re found what you need. Stay healthy, happy and safe. Pay as little as possible for something that both, your loved ones, and your insurance company hope is never used. Remember, only 1/3rd of the equation is life insurance rates.

Please follow and like us: